​

​

Valuation Guide for Software Stocks: Unveiling the Code Behind the Cash

Software stocks can be exciting investments. But their value can be trickier to assess compared to traditional companies. This guide will equip investors with the knowledge and tools to confidently evaluate and invest in software stocks. Let’s start navigating the software landscape.

Software Valuations: Understanding the Software Business Model

Let’s begin by breaking down the unique characteristics of software companies. This includes high recurring revenue, scalability, and network effects. Combined these create compounding value.

The two main types of software businesses are application and infrastructure. Which are fancy ways of saying front-end and back-end. Now if you’re in the industry, you will hear terms like SaaS, PaaS, on-premise. Software companies come in various flavors, impacting their valuation:

• SaaS (Software-as-a-Service): Recurring revenue through subscriptions is key. Focus on metrics like Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC), Customer Lifetime Value (CLTV), and churn rate.
• On-Premise Software: Revenue comes from upfront license sales and potentially maintenance fees. Look for strong brand recognition, established customer base, and recurring revenue streams.
• Freemium Model: Free basic features with paid premium tiers. User base and conversion rates become crucial metrics.

Software investors also focus on key trends and growth drivers in select industries. For example, you can be a vertical solution focused on healthcare and banking. Or a horizontal provider focused on enterprise solutions like ERP or CRM. Both do well but are valued differently.

While disruption is a catchy word, it tends to be vanity in most cases. Themes such as cloud computing, AI, and mobile adoption are technology accelerators more than disruptors. Which means, companies who use these technologies will get ahead of the competition. The ones that don’t, will fall behind.

Software Valuation Methods: Your Investment Compass

Most investors will attempt to apply the traditional valuation methods to software investments. Sure, they are applicable but don’t give you enough details on the technical nuances.

For example, the Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Ratio has limitations for software companies. With public stocks, earnings can be volatile because of stock compensation and R&D expenses can be bumpy. Both making it difficult to provide a clean valuation model.

The Price-to-Sales (P/S) Ratio can also be a challenge when valuing high-growth software companies. These stocks tend to deliver 25-30% annual growth rates while losing money. So the top-line and bottom-line financial statements will both tell different stories.

Instead more savvy investors will use advanced valuation metrics for Software Stocks. For many, this includes the Rule of 40 (Growth Rate + Profit Margin = 40%).

The term was first popularized by two notable venture capitalists: Brad Feld and Fred Wilson, back in 2015. The Rule assesses Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC), Lifetime Value (LTV) and Free Cash Flow (FCF) when valuing mature software companies. I recommend checking out the financial framework here.

The Rule of 40 states that a company's growth rate plus its profit margin should be greater than 40%. It indicates a healthy balance between growth and profitability. It exists for several key reasons:

1. Balancing Growth and Profitability:
   • SaaS companies often face a trade-off between prioritizing rapid growth (acquiring new customers) and achieving profitability (generating positive earnings).
   • The Rule of 40 provides a simple benchmark to evaluate how well a company is balancing these two crucial factors.
   • A healthy score above 40 indicates the company is finding a good balance, while a lower score might suggest it's sacrificing one for the other.
2. Investor Evaluation and Benchmarking:
   • Investors use the Rule of 40 as a quick gauge to assess the potential and sustainability of SaaS investments.
   • It allows for easy comparison of different SaaS companies based on their combined growth rate and profitability.
   • High scores generally signal attractive investment opportunities.
3. Guiding Management Decisions:
   • For SaaS company executives, the Rule of 40 acts as a strategic guidepost.
   • It helps them prioritize whether to focus on accelerating growth (even at the expense of short-term profits) or to shift towards profitability optimization.
4. Signaling Value Creation:
   • Studies have shown a correlation between companies exceeding the Rule of 40 and higher valuations.
   • This is because companies achieving this balance often demonstrate strong operational efficiency, competitive advantages, and sustainable growth.

Here are few important nuances:

• Not a rigid rule: There are exceptions and different interpretations of the Rule of 40. For example, early-stage startups may prioritize growth over profitability, while mature companies might focus more on profitability optimization.
• Focus on trends: It's crucial to track a company's Rule of 40 performance over time to understand if it's improving, declining, or remaining stable.
• Complementary metrics: The Rule of 40 is just one tool. Other SaaS metrics like customer acquisition cost (CAC), lifetime value (LTV), and churn should also be considered for a comprehensive evaluation.

In essence, the Rule of 40 serves as a valuable compass for both investors and SaaS companies. Helping them navigate the often challenging balance between growth and profitability in the dynamic software industry.

Assets & Cash Flow Considerations

Beyond the Numbers, I look at Qualitative Factors when investing. For software, that includes evaluating the product quality and assessing user adoption. Both help identify potential risks associated with the software product (e.g., security vulnerabilities, technical debt).

Then we can move onto analyzing the Team and Management. Which is essential when it comes to software. You need a technically strong team with a proven track record. The industry moves quick and talent moves quicker. For me, the company's culture and its ability to attract and retain talent are key.

Last is the growth potential and target market size. Not everything has a billion dollar revenue potential.

Also, don’t forget that software companies often have fewer tangible assets. Here's what to focus on:

• Intangible Assets: Intellectual property (IP) like patents and trademarks are crucial assets for software companies. Look for strong R&D investment and a robust patent portfolio.
• Recurring Revenue: Predictable, recurring revenue streams from subscriptions or maintenance contracts are highly valuable in software companies.
• Customer Base & Network Effects: A large, loyal customer base and strong network effects can create a competitive advantage and drive future growth.

Red Flags to Watch Out For

When investing in software stocks, develop a strategy that aligns with your risk tolerance. Compounding profitable cash flow stocks tends to be better performing high-growth, volatile businesses. Companies wont go bankrupt if they earn a profit.

Before I mentioned the importance of technical debt and product quality. When conducting due diligence, look at both more closely. If the team is not updating ideas on a regular basis, chances are there is too much backlog. Identifying potential red flags could signal overvaluation or future challenges. Avoid when possible.

Additional factors to consider when investing in software

• Unsustainable Growth: High growth rates are great, but unrealistic projections can be a warning sign. Look for a balance between growth and profitability.
• High Customer Churn: A high rate of customers canceling subscriptions can indicate a flawed product or service.
• Excessive Debt: While some debt can be acceptable, excessive leverage can be risky. Even for software companies, especially during downturns.

Navigating Software Investments: Your Roadmap

To begin your investment journey, I recommend looking through annual reports and SEC filings for financial data and company insights. Industry analysts are helpful if they have a background in technology. But I prefer looking at a company’s GitHub repository to better understand their product developments.

When investing, I recommend reviewing the rule of 40 and potential red flags specific to software companies again. Remember, software stock valuation is an art, not an exact science. But combining financial metrics with an understanding of the company's business model can give you a competitive edge.

Focus on long-term perspective investing. Great software companies tend to have negative working capital, healthy margins and a growing advantage. If you understand the volatility associated with growth stocks then you can capture a piece of this market. Stay informed on industry trends and happy hunting.